On pure specs, Zune looks like a damned good product. The very fact that it has Fairplay playback compatibility makes it the first serious challenge to iPod from anybody except maybe SanDisk (who suffer a bit from build quality issues.)
On principles (and I'm not getting anti Microsoft here, as such...), Zune has problems. From what I've read from a number of sources, the automatic DRM wrapper for
ANY song transfered to another zune via the wireless link breaches all the open source and public distributed licence terms out there.
On top of this, the money Macroslop collect to unlock these files may be paid to affilliated labels. Somebody transfers a Paul Brazier song wirelessly from Zune to Zune and the recipient likes it, pays for it to be unlocked and Universal or Sony get the dough.
Now
Reuters are reporting that a proportion of every Zune sold will be paid to Universal. This would be like the City of London paying General Motors a fee for every road built, even those rights-of-way where cars are forbidden. Worse than that, the sole reason for this is to make rights negotiations harder for Apple, or indeed any other legitemate retailer of music.
For me, it wouldn't matter if Zune cooked my breakfast, did the laundry and sucked and swallowed, until Macroslop address the rights issues, and stop playing fast and loose with independent and unsigned artists rights, I would sooner put my ears out with a pin than own one.